Latest issueVolleyball NCAA tournament opens at Ithaca College todayRead now

← Ithaca news

DowntownFriday, November 13

Downtown business owners push back on the city's plan to replace the Seneca Street garage with housing

The Daily Ithaca teamFrom Friday’s edition · 1 min read · 2 sources

ShareEmailFacebookX

If you park downtown, the Seneca Street garage is the fight to watch. The city shut the 425-space garage in April after debris began falling from its upper floors, and the Common Council is moving ahead with a plan to replace it with housing that has no parking requirement. Officials say downtown parking is still underused with the garage closed.

The garage went from closed to a council vote between April and September

  1. Apr. 10City closes the Seneca Street garage over rapid deterioration.
  2. May 7City shutters the garage permanently after an engineering review.
  3. Sept. 2Common Council votes 8-1 to transfer the garage to the IURA.
  4. Sept. 24IURA members vote unanimously to accept the council's resolution.
  5. Oct. 14City staff brief the Common Council on the garage's condition.

Business owners want the council to slow down. An online petition urges it to halt demolition plans and calls for an independent structural study. Moosewood owner Danica Wilcox told the council that about half of arriving dining parties send one person in first while the others circle the block.

The garage by the numbers

425
parking spaces in the garage
8-1
Common Council vote to transfer the site
About 970
signatures on the online petition
  • Age: 53 years, past its 30-to-50-year lifespan
  • Wanted: more housing, a new bus stop and shelter
  • Only no vote: Alderperson Margaret Fabrizio
  • Sale route: through the IURA, skipping auction or sealed bids

“A building that brings residents downtown and puts eyes on the street does far more for businesses than another concrete structure ever could.”

Mayor Robert Cantelmo, in an email

Sources: The Ithaca Voice, Ithaca Times

Read it in the full edition

More from Friday’s edition

Read the edition
All city hall news
  1. Ithaca Times14 hours ago

    Rising Fire Costs Prompt Ithaca Town Board to Override State Tax Cap in 2027 Budget, on Ithaca Times

    The Ithaca Town Board approved a $39.31 million budget for 2027 on Nov. 9, overriding the state property tax cap to cover a $1.17 million increase in fire protection costs.

  2. The Ithaca Voice23 hours ago

    Tompkins County Legislature adopts 2027 budget with 6.68% tax levy increase, on The Ithaca Voice

    After months of deliberation over what county officials have described as one of the most difficult budget years in recent memory, the Tompkins County Legislature adopted its 2027 budget Tuesday